Monday, November 16, 2026

Sex After Cigarettes

This idea of a "staggered age of consent" was in the news a lot yesterday. My mind kept floating back to the laws on cigarette sales, announced by Rishi Sunak's mandate-less government, then ratified by Starmer's Labour. The sliding scale, making it illegal for anyone born after 2009 to buy cigarettes.

I hate this idea. Partly because I fear the digital dog lead (naturally it leans into the need for ever more finicky ID checks at the checkout). But also, and more fundamentally, because it's such a detour from how the principle of fairness under the law should work. Thanks to it we will now have a situation where two grown adults will live under different rules. Let's say one is thirty-six and the other is thirty-five. One will have the right to buy cigarettes, the other will not.

It's such a bastardisation of law. A move from laws that rest upon a general principle to laws that are basically whatever the government wants to do, regardless of principle. Where basic freedoms can be adjusted the way governments change the retirement age or increase the rate of VAT.

"It's only cigarettes," I hear you say. Yet this only amplifies the sneakiness. It's a law that's essentially bypassed democracy, and that has bypassed the basic question, "Would I like to live under this law?"

It doesn't affect adults who don't smoke. It doesn't affect adults that do. It's a law for future generations, made by people in the present, who won't have to live under it. There's been very little public debate, because it doesn't affect the people that have the freedom to debate it. It's a classic example of, "Do as I say, not as I do." Only the government is the adult saying this, whilst the actual adults think, "Huh, this doesn't affect me, so I'm not bothered."

Of course, if the government thinks this way about cigarettes it stands to reason that it thinks this way about other things too. In fact, where these ideas emerge from is something of a mystery. We just seem to get a flurry of newspaper headlines, as if a swarm of wasps has arrived from a foreign land. Or a producer has pushed a button in The Truman Show (..and if you think that sounds conspiratorial, well it isn't - it's just how things normally work in countries that aren't democracies. Where a ruling class rules over the ruled. We have democracy, yet somehow we always seem to have these debates after the fact.)

Where did this weird cigarette law come from? Who voted for it? Where was the public debate before the law was brought into being?

Now we have a flurry of calls for a staggered age of consent. Riding the flurry of (understandable) emotion created by the Russell Brand scandal. If you question it you don't get debate though, you just get accused of being a sex offender yourself, lol.


Obviously a lot of people will just take the path of least resistance. No one wants to look like they're defending sexual predators. Especially if you're a man. It's not a good look. However, it's only a bit of mud, and people do have to debate it. As otherwise it'll potentially be another one of these progressive reforms pushed through on the back of feelings and "looking like a good person," that people come to regret over time.

A lot of people would support the age of consent being raised to eighteen, but that's not what's being proposed here. The proposal is a staggered age of consent. So the principle of adults being equal under the law (wherever you set the bar for adulthood) is at play. And unlike with cigarettes it'll have a huge knock-on effect for wider society. The chilling effect it'll have on male/female relationships alone will be enormous. We already see in the coverage of Brand and Walliams that it's not just sixteen and seventeen year olds that are portrayed as too young to consent. But girls nineteen, twenty, twenty-one..

Even from a moral point of view there's nothing wrong with, say, a twenty-eight year old falling in love with a twenty year ago and starting a relationship. It's maybe not ideal, but life isn't always ideal, and we can't choose who we fall in love with. However, under this direction of travel, suddenly these natural human impulses become legally grey. The perfectly well-intentioned man or woman might think, "I better stay away from this person, I'm doing something wrong." Even though they're potentially meeting the love of their life.

I'm not sure this is great for society.

Also, to end on a lighter note, there's that classic movie-scene notion of people having a cigarette after sex. It's funny to imagine some situation in the future where a forty year old man is lying in bed with a forty-one year old woman. She's smoking a cigarette, but he's not allowed to because the government won't let him.

No comments:

Post a Comment